Field study · July 2026
Do related Google Maps searches show the same businesses?
An electrician can rank for their trade and still miss the shortlist for a charger installation. We compared the first three names for five pairs of searches at the same point in 20 UK cities, then repeated the exercise the following day.
69 of 200 comparisons shared no names
Across all five pairs, the two searches returned the same three names on 8 occasions. The pairs behaved differently. Every electrician and EV charger comparison returned two separate shortlists. Every plumber and emergency plumber comparison shared at least one name. A search-term decision that makes sense for one trade can therefore miss an important distinction in another.
How many names did each pair share?
Each row counts 40 comparisons, one per city on each day. Column values count comparisons. The original order within a three-result list does not affect the overlap.
| Search terms | 0 shared names | 1 shared names | 2 shared names | 3 shared names |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Electricianev charger installation | 40 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Restaurantindian restaurant | 23 | 14 | 3 | 0 |
| Solicitorconveyancing solicitor | 4 | 12 | 24 | 0 |
| Plumberemergency plumber | 0 | 21 | 14 | 5 |
| Dentistdental implants | 2 | 15 | 20 | 3 |
Choose the second search from the work you want
Suppose your business has an electrical callout team and a separate diary for EV installation surveys. A customer searching for a charger installation has already specified the job. Check that phrase directly, follow the listing to your installation page and see whether the customer can request a survey. A screenshot for “electrician” alone cannot answer any of those questions. The electrical contractor guide separates callouts, inspections and planned work.
For a solicitor, even two shared names leave room for a different third result. In 24 of 40 comparisons, “solicitor” and “conveyancing solicitor” had exactly two names in common. If home purchases matter to the practice, include the conveyancing phrase in the report and test whether the branch page reaches the conveyancing team. Keep the broader phrase for enquiries that start with the firm rather than the transaction.
For a restaurant, a cuisine can narrow the shortlist much more sharply. In 23 comparisons, “restaurant” and “indian restaurant” had no common names. Use the cuisine that actually describes your menu. Make the same check from a point customers use, then see whether the menu and booking links are current on the listing they find. See all five Newcastle comparisons.
How to read and reproduce a comparison
- Choose one city and one UTC date in the CSV. Each observation compares two English-language Google Maps searches recorded from the same recorded city coordinate at zoom level 14. The first pass ran on 6 July 2026 and the repeat on 7 July.
- Take the first three stored listing names for each search in returned order. Count exact matches across the lists. If a title repeats, count only as many matches as the other list contains. A zero records two complete lists with no matching name.
- Filter to one query pair. Count the rows for each overlap value from zero to three and compare that count with the table. To examine consistency, filter to one date at a time. Repeats at the same point are paired observations.
The archive retained displayed names and positions without stable profile IDs. 16 comparisons contain a repeated title within at least one of the two lists. Branches can share a name, and a name can change. The figures describe what the names on the shortlists looked like on those dates. They cannot identify every underlying profile, establish why Google selected it or predict a result at another postcode.
The CSV contains one row per city, date and pair, including the duplicate-name flag. It contains no customer or lead data. For collection scope, cities and the wider set of 15 searches, read the original UK Maps study. To check a current business, start with a free Maps rank check for the service you actually want to measure.